ORTHODOX HOUSE
⛪ All churches
Sign in
🎧Live Music ☾
☦ Today Wednesday, October 14 / October 1 (old style) ✦ Fast day Gregorian calendar ⇄
Ven. Parasceva of Serbia · Holy Martyrs Nazarius, Gervasius, Protasius, and Celsus of Milan (1st c.)
← News feed Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate)

Did a loving God foresee the Fall?translated

October 14, 2026 · 1 min read

Reader question:

Hello. The Bible says that man disobeyed God and was expelled from paradise. Imagine: a parent leaves their children with a dangerous object, an attacker has access to them, and does not explain the consequences. Due to their inexperience, children violate the ban, they feel bad, and their father kicks them out of the house to a place of suffering. Can such a parent be considered loving? Could God have known that they would make a mistake and suffer?

Sergey

Priest's answer:

Priest Victor NIKISHOV

God bless you!

Your comparison of God to a parent who leaves their children with a dangerous object is not entirely accurate because it views the relationship with God in legal terms of crime and punishment. Saint John Chrysostom explains that even expulsion from paradise was not an act of anger, but an act of love: “So, God’s punishments themselves are blessings, they serve for correction, edification, instruction, and the suppression of evil. People do one thing as a benefit, another out of hatred and disgust; and God does everything out of love. As a benefactor, He settled man in paradise; as a benefactor, He expelled him from paradise.” Removal from the tree of life was not punishment, but mercy, so that a person, having sinned, would not remain alive...

Source: Журнал ФОМА  ·  Read the full story →
⚑ Report
💬 Comments
Sign in to join the conversation →
More stories
The spiritual and educational forum “Heritage of Orthodox culture and traditions of the Belarusian people” began work in Soligorsk
Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate) · October 14, 2026
Inter-Orthodox Vespers at Notre-Dame de Paris for the feast of Saint Dionysius the Areopagite – Sunday October 18 at 4:00 p.m.
Pan-Orthodox · October 14, 2026
Ecumenical Patriarch sends message of support to Pope Leo XIV
Pan-Orthodox · October 14, 2026
Sending of conscripts has begun in North Ossetia
Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate) · October 14, 2026
🔑Sign in 📖Prayer Book 🕊Live Prayer 📨Submit news 👥Friends 💬Groups ⛪My parish 🕯Virtual church 🙏Prayers by agreement 🗓Calendar ☦Lives of the Saints ✏️Catechesis 📚Library 🌍Orthodox World Review 🎧Live Music ⚖Canons 📜Holy Scripture 🧭Map of Orthodoxy ✅Test yourself 🔔Notifications ➕My subscriptions 🛍Store 💬Support