ORTHODOX HOUSE
⛪ All churches
Sign in
🎧Live Music ☾
☦ Today Tuesday, November 17 / November 4 (old style) 🍇 Wine and oil allowed Gregorian calendar ⇄
St Gregory the Wonderworker · Ven. Nikon of Radonezh
← News feed Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate)

A twin brother died in infancy. Why did he suffer and not me?translated

November 17, 2026 · 1 min read

Reader question:

A twin brother died in infancy. If God took him to Paradise automatically, it turns out that he was lucky, and not me? I'm afraid of failing the exam called life and going to hell. What is the value of earthly life with its temptations and sufferings? And if life is valuable and I was lucky, and not my brother, why did he, small and innocent, suffer? I love my brother, I think about him every day, although I don’t remember him.

Ksenia

Priest's answer:

Priest Victor NIKISHOV

God bless you!

The Church does not say that babies automatically go to Heaven. She hopes that God does not leave without Him those who did not have time to choose anything. Saint Gregory the Theologian, speaking about infants who died before baptism, said that they “will receive neither glory nor punishment,” because although they were not baptized, they were “not evil” and suffered more loss than they themselves committed evil. The Church does not say that dead babies will suffer in any way. We rather remain ignorant, leaving the matter to the mercy of God. Therefore, it makes no sense to say unequivocally which of you is luckier.

The Apostle John writes: “There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear, because in fear there is torment; afraid...

Source: Журнал ФОМА  ·  Read the full story →
⚑ Report
💬 Comments
Sign in to join the conversation →
More stories
ANNOUNCEMENT: Invitation to participate in the theatrical festival “Christmas Miracle” 2027 01/17/2027
Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate) · January 17, 2027
Call for Volunteers for the Patriarchal Humanitarian Mission
Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate) · December 31, 2026
Congratulations from Metropolitan Nikita of Krasnoyarsk and Achinsk on International Student Day
Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate) · November 17, 2026
Products in the church. Who can take them?
Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate) · November 17, 2026
🔑Sign in 📖Prayer Book 🕊Live Prayer 📨Submit news 👥Friends 💬Groups ⛪My parish 🕯Virtual church 🙏Prayers by agreement 🗓Calendar ☦Lives of the Saints ✏️Catechesis 📚Library 🌍Orthodox World Review 🎧Live Music ⚖Canons 📜Holy Scripture 🧭Map of Orthodoxy ✅Test yourself 🔔Notifications ➕My subscriptions 🛍Store 💬Support